How Polygraph Examiners Use Results to Gain Confessions

Polygraph Examiners

Understanding the Polygraph and Its Functions

A polygraph measures physiological responses. Responses such as heart rate, blood pressure, respiration, and skin conductivity, while a person answers a series of questions. The underlying theory is that deceptive answers will produce distinct physiological responses due to the stress and anxiety associated with lying. Polygraphists are trained to recognize these patterns and interpret the data in conjunction with the context of the questions asked. While not infallible, polygraphs provide a useful tool in the arsenal of investigators for identifying potential deceit, which can be pivotal in securing confessions.

The Role of Pre-Test Interviews

Before the polygraph examination begins, a pre-test interview is conducted. This session is crucial as it helps the examiner establish a baseline for the subject’s physiological responses and build rapport. During this interview, the examiner explains the polygraph process, sets expectations, and often subtly introduces the idea that the polygraph is highly accurate and reliable. This can create a psychological expectation in the subject that any attempt to deceive will be detected, thereby increasing anxiety levels in deceptive individuals. By fostering a belief in the accuracy of the polygraph, examiners can use this pre-test phase to subtly encourage subjects to be truthful, laying the groundwork for a confession later.

Conducting the Polygraph Examination

The polygraph examination itself consists of asking a series of questions while the subject’s physiological responses are recorded. These questions typically fall into three categories: irrelevant (neutral questions), relevant (directly related to the matter under investigation), and control questions (designed to provoke a physiological response regardless of truthfulness). By comparing responses to these different types of questions, polygraphists can identify inconsistencies that may indicate deception. If the results suggest the subject is lying, the examiner can use this information strategically during the post-test phase to elicit a confession.

Post-Test Interrogation Techniques

After the polygraph test, the examiner reviews the results with the subject. If the test indicates deception, the examiner may confront the subject with the findings. This moment is critical, as the subject may be more vulnerable and anxious due to the belief that the polygraph has exposed their deceit. Examiners often use a combination of confrontation, psychological pressure, and empathy to persuade the subject to confess. For example, the examiner might express an understanding of the subject’s situation, suggest that a confession is the best way to resolve the matter, or imply that the polygraph results are irrefutable, thereby leaving the subject with little choice but to admit the truth.

The Psychological Impact of Polygraph Results

The psychological impact of the polygraph examination on the subject cannot be overstated. Many subjects believe in the infallibility of the polygraph, and when confronted with evidence of deception, they may experience significant stress and anxiety. This psychological pressure can be a powerful motivator for confession, as the subject may feel cornered or see confession as a way to relieve the tension. Examiners are skilled in exploiting these psychological effects, using the subject’s emotional state to guide them toward admitting their guilt.

The Ethical Considerations in Securing Confessions

While polygraphists and examiners can use polygraph results effectively to secure confessions, there are important ethical considerations to keep in mind. The use of polygraph results as leverage must be balanced with the rights of the subject, particularly the right to avoid self-incrimination and the potential for false confessions. Examiners must ensure that their methods do not coerce or unduly pressure individuals into confessing to crimes they did not commit. This requires a careful and ethical approach, balancing the pursuit of truth with respect for the subject’s autonomy and legal rights.

Conclusion

Polygraph examinations serve as a powerful tool in the hands of skilled polygraphists and examiners, not only for detecting deception but also for securing confessions. By combining scientific analysis with psychological tactics, examiners can use polygraph results to encourage subjects to admit the truth. However, this process requires a careful balance between effective interrogation techniques and ethical considerations, particularly in light of the limitations and legal status of polygraph evidence. 

Here At Keefe Private Investigations and Process Serving in Oklahoma, we have polygraphists and polygraph examiners of great repute. So, for more insights or our services, visit us at www.privateinvestigatorokc.com you can email us at Makayla@ojpslegal.com.

Need Help?

Call Us

(405) 435-8355

Email

Makayla@ojpslegal.com

Would you like us to call you back?

Enter your info below

GREEN call icon